| Chairperson of the Board / Mayor Thomas Sapsea | Connor Lavertu |
| Angela Prysock / Princess Puffer | Lillian Graham |
| Alice Nutting / Edwin Drood / Dick Datchery | Joie Lynch |
| Clive Paget / John Jasper | Noah Alers Alers |
| James Throttle, Stage Manager | Nate Laporte |
| Deirdre Peregrine / Rosa Bud | Avery Fecteau |
| Janet Conover / Helena Landless | Alissa Cutting |
| Victor Grinstead / Neville Landless | Taylor Smith |
| Cedric Moncrieffe / Reverend Crisparkle | Enzo Valenti |
| Phillip Bax / Bazzard | Jack Downey |
| Nick Cricker, Sr. / Durdles | James Kelleher |
| Nicole Cricker / Deputy | Abby Carlson |
| Isobel Yearsley / Alice | Ashleigh Vittum |
| Florence Gill / Beatrice | Meredith Hoole |
| Company Members | Shakeira Baron |
| Taran Engelward |
| Shay Folger |
| Zoe Nagle |
| Haley Serafine |
